Player Ratings: Liverpool 2–3 West Brom


Simon Mignolet – 5

Wasn’t decisive enough and didn’t inspire confidence – wasn’t called upon much but when he was he didn’t deliver – was fortunate with West Brom’s disallowed third.

Trent Alexander-Arnold – 5

Made a couple of useful runs forward during the first-half but was more restricted in the second – did produce one or two good crosses in the final minutes as Liverpool searched for an equaliser.

Joel Matip – 6

Was non-existent as West Brom waltzed through to goal to turn the tie around – looked overawed and shaky throughout and he will be the first to admit it was a poor defensive display.

Virgil van Dijk – 5

Did not defend with the assuredness and character that was expected – made a handful of errors in dangerous situations and was sloppy in possession.

Alberto Moreno – 6

Played much deeper in the second-half such was the threat of West Brom on the counter-attack but didn’t hugely impress on his return to the team.

Alex Oxlade-Chamberlain – 5

Quality in possession was lacking and all too often didn’t capitalise on poor West Brom defending – was one of the three players who went off just after the hour mark.

Emre Can – 5

In recent matches Can has run the game for Liverpool but on Saturday he was overrun by it – lost possession too many times and didn’t dictate the play as he is capable.

Georginio Wijnaldum – 5

Picked up a slight knock in the opening minute and never moved freely from then on – wasn’t intense enough and the match rather passed him by.

Mohamed Salah – 6

Scored Liverpool’s second but struggled to engineer enough space to create in and around the visitors’ area – kept Dawson and Evans on their toes.

Sadio Mane – 5

Like Salah, he failed to really create anything in the tightly packed West Brom area – did grow into the game in the second-half but was also taken off.

Roberto Firmino – 7

Scored a beautiful chip within the opening five minutes before missing a penalty half-way through the first-half which really could have changed the outcome of the match.

West Brom

Ben Foster 8

Made an error early on that led to Firmino’s opener but once that was out of the way it was a near perfect performance – assured when claiming crosses and demonstrated his reflexes with a number of fine saves.

Allan Nyom – 7

Kept Mane pretty quiet on the right and stuck to the basics before switching to left-back and limiting the influence of Salah.

Craig Dawson – 7

Scored a headed goal which was disallowed – appeared quite nervy in defence at times and hacked at some clearances but saw ought the victory from right-back.

Jonny Evans – 6

Partly to blame for Firmino’s opener and, like Dawson, wasn’t very sturdy in the Albion defence – if it is to be his final performance in blue and white, it wasn’t his best.

Kieran Gibbs – 6

Went off on 37 minutes with a hamstring injury after playing fairly well – his replacement Hegazi impressed in the second-half.

Jake Livermore – 8

Tucked in for most of the second-half to make a West Brom back six – was confident when going forward down the right-side.

Gareth Barry – 7

Played well and screened the back four excellently – was taken off with 20 minutes to play after giving his all.

Grzegorz Krychowiak – 8

A very good display from the Pole – dominated the midfield and was involved in many of West Brom’s attacks – unlike the other midfielders on the pitch he thrived in the tight spaces.

Chris Brunt – 7

Like Livermore on the right, he blocked the flow of traffic and tucked in during the second-half – also played a number of fine balls to the West Brom attackers.

Hal Robson-Kanu – 7

Was a nuisance to the Liverpool defence until he was forced off just before half-time with an injury – played a major role in the first two Albion goals.

Jay Rodriguez – 8

A fine display from the striker – produced a superb drive to equalise for the visitors and neatly finished to put them ahead – has scored five goals since the end of December and looks to be relishing his opportunity.

Oliver Miller

FoL's Matchday Correspondent @oliver_miller

liverpool fc win fa cup 2022

What Are Liverpool’s Chances Of Success This Season?

The 2023/24 Premier League season promises to have one of the most exciting run-ins of recent times, with three teams all in with a realistic chance of lifting the trophy, with just 10 games to go. Liverpool, Arsenal and Manchester City each have realistic chances and for the former, it could mean a fairytale finish […]

Read More
this is anfield we are liverpool sign in the stadium

How Liverpool FC Captured the Hearts of Millions Worldwide

With a rich history dating back to 1892, Liverpool Football Club has not only achieved remarkable success on the pitch but has also played a pivotal role in uniting people from various walks of life. The passion, loyalty, and spirit of the Anfield faithful are what make Liverpool FC stand out in the world of […]

Read More
Steven Gerrard Feature Image

Why Steven Gerrard should have prolonged his career and helped Jurgen Klopp achieve Liverpool’s ambitions

I’ve always wanted to write about the idea that Steven Gerrard quit too soon. This article will explore the argument that had the former Liverpool captain carried on just a few seasons longer, he could have ended on a high note and helped Klopp’s side get over the line for some vital silverware. Gerrard quit […]

Read More