Player Ratings: Liverpool 2–3 West Brom


Simon Mignolet – 5

Wasn’t decisive enough and didn’t inspire confidence – wasn’t called upon much but when he was he didn’t deliver – was fortunate with West Brom’s disallowed third.

Trent Alexander-Arnold – 5

Made a couple of useful runs forward during the first-half but was more restricted in the second – did produce one or two good crosses in the final minutes as Liverpool searched for an equaliser.

Joel Matip – 6

Was non-existent as West Brom waltzed through to goal to turn the tie around – looked overawed and shaky throughout and he will be the first to admit it was a poor defensive display.

Virgil van Dijk – 5

Did not defend with the assuredness and character that was expected – made a handful of errors in dangerous situations and was sloppy in possession.

Alberto Moreno – 6

Played much deeper in the second-half such was the threat of West Brom on the counter-attack but didn’t hugely impress on his return to the team.

Alex Oxlade-Chamberlain – 5

Quality in possession was lacking and all too often didn’t capitalise on poor West Brom defending – was one of the three players who went off just after the hour mark.

Emre Can – 5

In recent matches Can has run the game for Liverpool but on Saturday he was overrun by it – lost possession too many times and didn’t dictate the play as he is capable.

Georginio Wijnaldum – 5

Picked up a slight knock in the opening minute and never moved freely from then on – wasn’t intense enough and the match rather passed him by.

Mohamed Salah – 6

Scored Liverpool’s second but struggled to engineer enough space to create in and around the visitors’ area – kept Dawson and Evans on their toes.

Sadio Mane – 5

Like Salah, he failed to really create anything in the tightly packed West Brom area – did grow into the game in the second-half but was also taken off.

Roberto Firmino – 7

Scored a beautiful chip within the opening five minutes before missing a penalty half-way through the first-half which really could have changed the outcome of the match.

West Brom

Ben Foster 8

Made an error early on that led to Firmino’s opener but once that was out of the way it was a near perfect performance – assured when claiming crosses and demonstrated his reflexes with a number of fine saves.

Allan Nyom – 7

Kept Mane pretty quiet on the right and stuck to the basics before switching to left-back and limiting the influence of Salah.

Craig Dawson – 7

Scored a headed goal which was disallowed – appeared quite nervy in defence at times and hacked at some clearances but saw ought the victory from right-back.

Jonny Evans – 6

Partly to blame for Firmino’s opener and, like Dawson, wasn’t very sturdy in the Albion defence – if it is to be his final performance in blue and white, it wasn’t his best.

Kieran Gibbs – 6

Went off on 37 minutes with a hamstring injury after playing fairly well – his replacement Hegazi impressed in the second-half.

Jake Livermore – 8

Tucked in for most of the second-half to make a West Brom back six – was confident when going forward down the right-side.

Gareth Barry – 7

Played well and screened the back four excellently – was taken off with 20 minutes to play after giving his all.

Grzegorz Krychowiak – 8

A very good display from the Pole – dominated the midfield and was involved in many of West Brom’s attacks – unlike the other midfielders on the pitch he thrived in the tight spaces.

Chris Brunt – 7

Like Livermore on the right, he blocked the flow of traffic and tucked in during the second-half – also played a number of fine balls to the West Brom attackers.

Hal Robson-Kanu – 7

Was a nuisance to the Liverpool defence until he was forced off just before half-time with an injury – played a major role in the first two Albion goals.

Jay Rodriguez – 8

A fine display from the striker – produced a superb drive to equalise for the visitors and neatly finished to put them ahead – has scored five goals since the end of December and looks to be relishing his opportunity.

About the Author

Oliver Miller
FoL's Matchday Correspondent @oliver_miller