Player Ratings: Manchester City 5–0 Liverpool

Player Ratings


Simon Mignolet – 6

Although conceded 5 goals, was hard to pinpoint ultimate blame when he was left so exposed.

Trent Alexander-Arnold – 4

The teenager’s strengths are attacking and technique but his defensive frailty was apparent and exploited.

Joel Matip – 4

Failed to take part in the match – absent as De Bruyne played in Aguero for the opener and was not close enough to Jesus for the second.

Ragnar Klavan – 4

Replaced Lovren for this match and possibly Klopp missed a trick by not using a mannequin instead of him.

Alberto Moreno – 5

Like Trent, main strengths are attacking and so City’s all-star strikers were buoyed by his invisibility in defensive situations.

Georginio Wijnaldum – 4

Allowed City’s midfield too much time and space and never had any meaningful possession.

Jordan Henderson – 5

Liverpool’s captain exerted little grip on proceedings and gave away possession for City’s opener.

Emre Can – 4

Never got into the game and his most memorable moment was a poorly executed free-kick on the edge of the City penalty area.

Mohamed Salah – 6

Playing between Mendy and Otamendi, every one-on-one promised a goal, only for Salah’s decision-making to let him down. Guardiola did perceive him as a threat and thus switched Otamendi from left- to right-side of defence at half-time.

Roberto Firmino – 5

Did not have many chances but did escape from Danilo only to shoot when a pass could have brought a goal when the scores were still level.

Sadio Mane – 5

Had looked lively before being sent off by referee Moss for serious foul play.

Manchester City

Ederson – 7

The young Brazilian’s game ended with Mane’s challenge but did manage to take a seat on the bench to see his side complete the rout in which he had impressed whilst playing.

Danilo – 5

Looked quite nervy and unconvincing playing at centre-back during the first-half.

John Stones – 5

Was tested by Liverpool’s early attacks and never really exhibit his passing abilities.

Nicolas Otamendi – 3

Could not cope with Salah and was lucky not to concede a penalty and brake Mane’s ribs in the first-half.

Kyle Walker – 7

Enjoyed running head-first at Moreno and his physicality enabled him to cover the whole of the left side.

Fernandinho – 5

City’s only specialist central midfielder directed the game and played a wonderful pass to set up the third goal.

Kevin De Bruyne – 8

Head and shoulders above everyone else on the pitch – was gifted time and space by Liverpool’s defence and midfield and used them delightfully by creating throughout.

David Silva – 7

A vital cog in City’s attack – conducting the passing that enabled City to exploit the gaps in Liverpool’s defence

Benjamin Mendy – 6

Was strong when attacking against Alexander-Arnold and benefited from the free space left by Mane but did not help his defensive partner, Otamendi, when Salah was attacking frequently early-on.

Gabriel Jesus – 8

Scored twice and had another disallowed but perhaps more importantly showed that he was capable of playing as a duo with Aguero.

Sergio Aguero – 7

Opened the scoring with a well-timed run and calm finish around Mignolet and also set up Jesus for City’s third.

Oliver Miller

FoL's Matchday Correspondent @oliver_miller

Steven Gerrard Feature Image

Why Steven Gerrard should have prolonged his career and helped Jurgen Klopp achieve Liverpool’s ambitions

I’ve always wanted to write about the idea that Steven Gerrard quit too soon. This article will explore the argument that had the former Liverpool captain carried on just a few seasons longer, he could have ended on a high note and helped Klopp’s side get over the line for some vital silverware. Gerrard quit […]

Read More
The Loan Report

Sturridge returns to action, but it’s all about five-star Wilson

Harry Wilson – Hull City Harry Wilson scored his fifth goal in Hull colours when he opened the scoring for their 5-0 thrashing of Burton Albion. The Welshman picked up the ball on the right-hand side of the box, before accurately placing it in the far corner of the net. From that point on Hull […]

Read More
Talking Points

Key Talking Points As Salah And Co. Cruise Past Bournemouth

Anfield, Liverpool – This is a strange time, a time when Premier League football has almost become an afterthought for Liverpool Football Club. In spite of whatever may be going on in various competitions though, every team still has to play their 38 league games. Jurgen Klopp, perhaps surprisingly elected to field a very strong […]

Read More